Instant, Online and Unlimited

Wyoming Auto

Insurance Quotes

Wyoming Auto Insurance Quotes

Researching Wyoming auto insurance quotes and which company’s best rates for insuring your car can be time-consuming. Nobody got time for that. Don’t you worry, we will do most of the work for you? In the busiest cities of Equality State, we have evaluated the two atypical drivers. We found a range of insurance companies offering premiums anywhere from $746 to $1089. Whether you are or what kind of auto insurance coverage you are looking for, we can help you get the best deals in your area here at Insurance Quote Deals.


Looking for Low-Cost Auto Insurance in Wyoming?


We’ve got the skinny from some of the biggest names in insurance on who has the best insurance quote deals. When averaged across the state, the research of the two most common drivers in Wyoming found that Geico, Grange, and State Farm had the most affordable Auto Insurance rates.  These companies’ standard annual liability coverage was $844, 18% below the state’s average.

Allstate and California Casualty had some of the most expensive quotes on the opposite end of the spectrum, with a typical yearly premium of $1467. That is 22% more cost direct towards you. It would only be fair to remember, though; California Casualty is a specialty insurance company for specific representatives of certain lines of work. Below we have visually ranked the top auto insurance companies and their average cost for yearly liability coverage.


Affordable Auto Insurance in Wyoming: by City


To provide you with a better perspective on the insurers with the best insurance quotes in your area, we have collected information on the ten largest cities in Wyoming. The calculations are just an average. Your rates will vary based on your life factors. In the chart below, we have ranked insurance companies from lowest cost to highest cost in each of these Wyoming cities.

Wyoming LocationLow-Cost Insurer #2Low-Cost Insurer #2Low-Cost Insurer #3
CheyenneGrange$807Geico$756State Farm$846
CasperGrange787Geico783State Farm939
LaramieGrange883Grange841State Farm950
GilletteGeico811Grange773State Farm900
Rock SpringsGeico873Grange834State Farm976
SheridanGeico692Grange847State Farm885
Green RiverGeico877Grange749State Farm969
EvanstonGeico821Grange905State Farm885
RivertonGeico871Grange870State Farm833
JacksonGrange943Geico889State Farm996


Cities with the Lowest Priced Auto Insurance in Wyoming

With an average price of $865 annually, these five cities have the lowest auto coverage costs of Wyoming’s ten most occupied towns.


Cheyenne, Wyoming

Cheyenne is the largest city in Wyoming, with an average cost of auto insurance of $913 annually. The northern curtain of the ever-growing Front Range Urban Corridor reaches Colorado. In the 2010 Census, its population was 59,466, making it the most populous city in the state. Cheyenne is home to several National Historic Landmarks, including Fort Yellowstone, and it is the Wyoming State Capitol.


Casper, Wyoming

Also known as “The Oil City,” Casper has thick roots in the oil industry and cowboy culture. With a population of 55,316, according to the 2010 census, it is ranked as the second-largest city in Wyoming. We find it at the foot of Casper Mountain along the North Platte River. In this proper blue mountain city, auto insurance rates are some of the lowest in the state, average at $993 yearly.


Laramie, Wyoming

Laramie is the county seat of Albany County, with a population of 30,816 per the 2010 Census. The average annual insurance rate in this city is $965. Everyone can locate Laramie on the Laramie River in southeast Wyoming, west of Cheyenne. It is the location of Wyoming State University and Wyoming Technical Institute. Laramie is also the home of what remains of Fort Sanders, a fort that predates the town itself.


Gillette, Wyoming

In the city that calls itself “The Energy Capital of the Nation,” Gillette provides 35% of the nation’s coal. It also produces vast quantities of energy from other sources such as oil and coal bed methane gas. The city’s population continues to grow, but its auto insurance rates are at all-time lows averaging $852 annually.


Rock Springs, Wyoming

Located in Sweetwater County, Rock Springs is the central city in the metropolitan area. Rock Springs has a population of 23,036. Everyone recognizes it as the Home of 56 Nationalities because of the surge of immigrants who came to the city for work in the coal mines at the beginning of the Union Pacific Railroad. The city continues to have a rich culture, and they celebrate this every summer on International Day. Everyone here has in common the benefit of low-cost auto insurance rates as low as $782 yearly.


Sheridan, Wyoming

Named after the Union cavalry leader General Phillip Sheridan, the city is one of the top-rated western towns. According to the 2010 census, the city’s population is 17,444, and people locate it on the border of Montana. Outdoor enthusiasts are drawn here for various outdoor activities and the Big Horn Mountains. The average annual auto insurance rate is $828, making it one of the lowest in the state.


Cities with the Highest Priced Auto Insurance


With an average price of $1,365, these five cities in Wyoming have the highest cost of auto insurance in the state. But unfortunately, they are also some of the least populated.


Van Tassell, Wyoming

Located in Niobrara County is the town of Van Tassell. According to the 2010 Census, only 15 people live in this town. This town holds the unofficial title of being the least populated town in the least populated county and the least populated state. The auto insurance rates for this town are a part of the highest at about $1375 annually.


Wright, Wyoming

Wright is the next town with some of the most expensive auto insurance rates in the state at $1,398. The city settled in the center of Campbell County, and the 2010 US Census recorded 1,807 people. The settlement began in the 1970s due to the construction of the Black Thunder Coal Mine. Today the town is still very much a coal mining town.

Buffalo, WY

With a small population of 4 585 people, Buffalo sits in Johnson County and is the county seat. The auto insurance rates are some of the highest, with the average at $1243. However, the small town has experienced a recent economic boom due to coal bed methane extraction in the Powder River Basin.


Douglas, Wyoming


Home of the Wyoming State Fair, Douglas is nestled in Converse County. In the 2010 Census, authorities recorded the population at 6,120. It was known as “The Tent City” before being named after senator Stephen A. Douglas. The Wyoming Central Railway was built in 1886 and is also considered a historical landmark. The yearly auto insurance rates are high here at about $1392.


Lander, WY

Lander has some of the most expensive annual rates in the state at $1297. As the county seat of Fremont County, we locate it beside the Middle Fork of the Pogo Angie River. In addition, we also find Lander south of the Wind River Indian Reservation. Art is at the Center of this community.


Top Auto Insurance Companies in Wyoming

We have researched consumer data and compiled a list of Wyoming’s best auto insurance companies. We have made a comprehensive list but using both customer complaints against the cost of premiums. In this list, the higher the number of complaints, the worse the company is from a buyer’s point of view. Conversely, the lower number of complaints, the better a company is.

Company# of Closed ComplaintsDirect Premium Written ($MM)
State Farm Insurance7$36
Progressive Insurance19146
Allstate Insurance1687
Mountain West Farm Bureau Mutual1434
Farmers / Fire Insurance Exchange1127
Safeco Insurance Company of America415
Mid-Century Insurance 57
Dairyland Insurance / Viking Insurance88

Cost of Auto Insurance by City in Wyoming

Here we have ranked lower-priced coverage in the highest price range. However, our premium comparison is for the average driver in Wyoming.

CityAve. Rate($)
Fort Washakie1095
Green River1172
Rock Springs1285
Van Tassell1278


Get A Quote!